Law360: NRA Seeks 2nd Circ. Rehearing In Free Speech Dispute

October 11, 2022 - Law360 reports that Brewer client, the National Rifle Association of America (NRA), is asking a "Second Circuit panel for a rehearing after the court found that an investigation into insurers partnered with the NRA and statements by a former New York official advising NRA-affiliated businesses to assess their reputational risks did not violate the gun advocacy group's constitutional rights."

The NRA filed a petition for rehearing en banc on October 6, 2022, asserting that the three-judge panel that overturned its free speech win ignored "clearly-established law that selective enforcement regimes violate the First Amendment." The panel's decision reversed a district court ruling, resulting in the dismissal of individual claims against former Department of Financial Services Superintendent Maria Vullo.  

"The NRA believes, as do most First Amendment scholars, that a government official should not be allowed to target her political enemies and then weaponize the power of her office against that group. The concept, which is unremarkable, restrains 'viewpoint discrimination,'" William A. Brewer III, counsel for the NRA, said in a statement to Law360.

"Numerous legal experts and constitutional scholars join the NRA in recognizing the First Amendment forbids such action. The association will continue to pursue this matter in support of its members and their constitutional freedoms," Brewer said.

Read the report (subscription required). 

New York Law Journal: Judge's Ruling Allows NRA's First Amendment Claims to Proceed

On March 15, 2021, the New York Law Journal reported that a ruling by U.S. District Judge Thomas McAvoy of the Northern District of New York allows the NRA's First Amendment claims against New York state officials to move forward with discovery.

The lawsuit argues that New York state officials violated the NRA's First Amendment rights to express its political views.

“This important decision reaffirms that all public officials, even Gov. Cuomo and Maria Vullo, the former superintendent of the New York State Department of Financial Services, are accountable under the First Amendment,” said William Brewer, counsel to the NRA. “It will allow the NRA to pursue discovery and bring important evidence to light—to expose the communications and coordinated efforts of New York officials and others to harm the NRA and impinge its Constitutional freedoms. The message is clear: the NRA will stand up to those who unlawfully interfere with its Second Amendment advocacy.”

The article reports that Judge McAvoy denied qualified immunity to former New York Department of Financial Services (DFS) superintendent Maria Vullo, noting that "a question of material fact exists" as to whether Vullo "explicitly threatened" an insurer with DFS enforcement unless it broke ties with the NRA.

Read more.