April 2008 — Hospitality Law reports that the "Ritz-Carlton Hotel Co. was slapped with a $10 million verdict after a District Court jury found the hotel violated its fiduciary duties to an Indonesian property owner" — firm client Karang Mas Sejahtera (KMS).
The article, "Jury Awards Bali Hotel Operator $10.3 Million Verdict," states that the jury in the Greenbelt, Maryland, case found that the Ritz violated its operating agreement with KMS by opening a competing luxury property within three miles of KMS's property, the Ritz-Carlton Bali Resort & Spa.
According to the report, Bill Brewer, counsel to KMS and a partner at Bickel & Brewer, told Hospitality Law that the case "clarifies the rights, responsibilities and obligations of all parties involved in a hotel management agreement and affirmed that his client's position that the Ritz-Carlton breached its fiduciary duty from a financial, operational and competitive point of view."
"It doesn't matter what you call a relationship — if someone is managing your business, your assets, for your benefit and being paid handsomely to do that, they owe you a fiduciary duty," Brewer said. "The Ritz-Carlton attempted to claim that they and their subsidiary didn't have a fiduciary responsibility to the owner [of the Bali property], and the jury absolutely decided otherwise. I think it reminded everybody that between a principal and an agent, honesty and fact are the touchstone of the relationship."